Garrison Keillor closes each "Lake Wobegon" portion of Prairie Home Companion with this line: "Lake Wobegon, where the women are strong, the men are good looking, and all of the children are above average."
It's fair to say that PC's dad and much of his family grew up in a version of Lake Wobegon. Though I would not admit this until I was at least 21, the show's keen understanding of small town Minnesota/America along with Keillor's sense of humor and love of song attracted me to PHC. He's a bit sneaky and more than a little judgmental in his humor, but you forget that because the sonorous voice and "aw shucks" authenticity are disarming. But what is he saying about Lake Wobegon? We know it's impossible, by definition, for all Lake Wobegonian children to be above average, which is the clue that this is satire on the idea of perfect kids and the parents who would raise them. It's a joke made at the expense of those of us who push our kids too hard, who are too tied up in whatever given metric is being used to measure them (from height/weight as babies to SATs as teenagers). Keillor is telling us that the metrics are worth reconsidering. To push even further--he is saying that it is a vice to push for that kind of perfection in the first place, to make all these measurements.
How could it be a vice to push your kids to achieve a better SAT? Well, I can only imagine how we'd react if PC comes out "below average" in school or the Pinewood Derby or in something else a few years down the line. Even if I logically know that being "below average" in something is "normal," I'm also sure that such a mark would motivate us as parents to try to help him do better. This is because in my experience metrics like these are really not neutral observations of some phenomena, they're commands. To talk of averages is to make measurements against others, which means there's an impulse toward competition built in and a slew of cultural expectations attached. Average. It's a vice to push for perfect children not just because it's devastating for them to feel continually like they fell short, but also because expecting perfection leads us to underappreciate how our shortcomings make us unique human beings. To expect perfect every time is to corrode the soul. There are ways to lose with grace and dignity.
I'm sure that some parents need to step away from the child a bit, but for most of us, this is a mistake. A laissez-faire brand of parenting abdicates responsibility and forfeits the millions of little opportunities parents have to teach kids about the world. While some parents need to let the kid breathe a bit, most of us need to "get in the way," just not at the expense of our kid's well-being and a healthy sense of their own abilities. I suspect that parents of Lake Wobegon know this, and that they probably report that their children are above average with a wink and a nudge.


